« Artist Sample: Favorite D Songs | Main | News: tetsu of L'Arc~en~Ciel Engaged... Sorta »

11/13/2007

Comments

Heroin(e)

[this is good]

Oh god. Silver Ash is indeed a wonderful band. I got one of their CDs in Beijing last year after hearing some of their songs and they just blew me away.


It's so sad to see one of China's first visual kei bands struggling like this though. :(


If it weren't for the government, I can totally see them rocking the world. :]

binaryrose

It's strange, I've just reached the level of competency in reading/writing Chinese to begin to truly appreciate Ling's lyrics, and looking back on the whole (what little there is, unfortunately) history of Silver Ash, I can't help but think "if only it they had toned it down a bit more in the beginning," or something of the like that wouldn't have made them such a red flag.

Aural Candy

I don't get why the government wants to crack down on Silver Ash. Surely it's not because of visual kei, for SA is by no means the only visual kei band in China. And Japanese VK bands would not have been allowed to perform in China if that's the case. If it's because of the controversial messages of one or two songs, they're rather innocuous in the grand scheme of things. The party-state has a remarkably wide "zone of indifference". SA should be below its notice.

I'm not convinced that it's entirely the Chinese government's fault. I'd like to just ask Ling to explain why and how exactly they left their label. Though, he'll probably talk about it in his band history overview blog entries... a year from now. >_>

Aural Candy

I don't get why the government wants to crack down on Silver Ash.
Surely it's not because of visual kei, for SA is by no means the only
visual kei band in China. And Japanese VK bands would not have been
allowed to perform in China if that's the case. If it's because of the
controversial messages of one or two songs, they're rather innocuous in
the grand scheme of things. The party-state has a remarkably wide "zone
of indifference". SA should be below its notice.

I'm not convinced that it's entirely the Chinese government's fault.
I'd like to just ask Ling to explain why and how exactly they left
their label. Though, he'll probably talk about it in his band history
overview blog entries... a year from now. >_>

(Sorry I wrote the exactly same response. I have to run now. ^_^;;)

The comments to this entry are closed.